$169/mo - Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Shelter Island 11964
| Compare by Car | Providers in 11964 | Quotes /mo* |
|---|---|---|
| Subaru | Progressive | $196 |
| Odyssey | Progressive | $228 |
| Ford | Progressive | $222 |
| Jeep | Progressive | $238 |
| Nissan | Progressive | $235 |
| Honda | Progressive | $247 |
| Chevrolet | Progressive | $256 |
| Dodge | Progressive | $258 |
| Toyota | Progressive | $264 |
| Audi | Progressive | $285 |
| BMW | Progressive | $330 |
| Tesla | Progressive | $325 |
| Cadillac | Progressive | $352 |
*Note: Cheapest car insurance quotes in Shelter island 11964 for the SUV/Truck versions could vary by 5-20%. Contact Providers in 11964 below for custom quotes. You may also want to check how your credit score and age/sex affects quotes before contacting providers.
OR
| Insurance Provider | |||
|---|---|---|---|
Progressive |
|||
|
|||
Compare by FICO in shelter island 11964
Compare by Age/Sex in shelter island 11964
Note: The tables/charts represent the cheapest car insurance quotes in Shelter island 11964. The driving profile in shelter island 11964 is that of a single driver. The car driven is a base model with an average age under 5 years in the State of New York.
2023 Car Insurance Calculator for New York 11964
Car Insurance calculator table below shows how each specific incident affects the total car insurance costs in New York Shelter island 11964 on an average.
| Incident in New York 11964 | Extra Cost/mo | % change |
|---|---|---|
| Ticket | $287 | 13% |
| Accident | $317 | 27% |
| Lapse | $264 | 6% |
| DUI/DWI* | $399 | 60% |
| Home Owner Bundle | $241 | -3% |