$1030/yr - Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico

The table below lists 2023 Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico, along with details of providers, agents, and agencies. Please select a zip code to view specific information about agents and see additional quotes based on the model of your car. Ask Insuranzy AI for answers.

   


Cheapest Quotes in New Mexico
Insurance Agency Quotes*

AAA

$2,167/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by AAA is $164 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.
  • AAA ($178 /month )
    Albuquerque West Branch
    9231 Coors Rd NW Ste 5&6
    Zip 87114 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • AAA ($170 /month )
    Albuquerque East Branch
    10501 Montgomery Blvd NE
    Zip 87111 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • AAA ($176 /month )
    Santa Fe Branch
    3517 Zafarano Dr Ste D
    Zip 87507 Santa Fe - New Mexico

Allstate

$2,111/yr


American-Family

$1,392/yr


Amica

$1,511/yr


Farmers

$1,962/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by Farmers is $157 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.
  • Farmers ($154 /month )
    Salinas
    3211 Coors Blvd SW
    Zip 87121 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($146 /month )
    David Zambrano
    100 Sun Ave NE
    Zip 87109 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($149 /month )
    Daniel Silva
    1102 Mtn Rd NW
    Zip 87102 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($148 /month )
    Brandon McFatridge
    4300 Silver Ave SE
    Zip 87108 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($146 /month )
    Armando Barquero
    901 Rio Grande Blvd NW
    Zip 87104 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($159 /month )
    Robert Trujillo
    122 Tulane Dr SE
    Zip 87106 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($147 /month )
    Catherine Olague
    2745 San Mateo Blvd NE
    Zip 87110 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($159 /month )
    Leroy Sisneros
    1641 Isleta Blvd SW
    Zip 87105 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($152 /month )
    Larissa Luce
    2641 Coors Blvd NW
    Zip 87120 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($155 /month )
    Elizabeth Mendez
    223 Montano Rd NW
    Zip 87107 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Farmers ($147 /month )
    David Vigil
    103 Rio Rancho Dr NE
    Zip 87124 Rio Rancho - New Mexico

Geico

$1,171/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by Geico is $81 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.

Nationwide

$1,362/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by Nationwide is $104 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.
  • Nationwide ($109 /month )
    Usa Insurance Inc.
    3310 N White Sands Blvd
    Zip 88310 Alamogordo - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($101 /month )
    Canyon Lands Insurance 1 Inc.
    1204 Mary Ellen St NE
    Zip 87112 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($109 /month )
    Minick & Company Inc.
    541 Paisano St NE
    Zip 87123 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($104 /month )
    Agsure Inc.
    5501 Eagle Rock Ave NE
    Zip 87113 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($103 /month )
    J S Ward & Son Inc.
    101 S 4th St
    Zip 88210 Artesia - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($96 /month )
    Metro East Insurance Group Inc.
    240 S Camino Del Pueblo
    Zip 87004 Bernalillo - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($99 /month )
    Wafd Insurance Group, Inc.
    203 W Mermod St
    Zip 88220 Carlsbad - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($99 /month )
    Alcorn Insurance Agency Inc.
    457 Terrace Ave
    Zip 87520 Chama - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($108 /month )
    Western States Insurance Group
    1001 E Llano Estacado Blvd
    Zip 88101 Clovis - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($103 /month )
    Tooter Cosper Insurance Agency
    3949 Corrales Rd
    Zip 87048 Corrales - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($106 /month )
    Rio Grande Insurance Services Of Sf
    1116 Plaza Del Norte
    Zip 87532 Espanola - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($109 /month )
    Kysar Millennium Leavitt Insurance
    300 W Arrington St
    Zip 87401 Farmington - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($108 /month )
    Zenity Insurance LLC
    3832 E Main St
    Zip 87402 Farmington - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($107 /month )
    Clay Fultz Agency, Inc.
    201 E Aztec Ave
    Zip 87301 Gallup - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($97 /month )
    Griggs Insurance Agency Inc.
    32 State Highway 89
    Zip 88121 House - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($109 /month )
    Grindell & Romero Insurance Inc.
    1121 Mall Dr
    Zip 88011 Las Cruces - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($101 /month )
    The Bernal Insurance Agency
    1591 E Lohman Ave
    Zip 88001 Las Cruces - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($98 /month )
    Hunton Insurance Agency
    122 S Avenue A
    Zip 88130 Portales - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($101 /month )
    Meridian Fh New Mexico LLC
    601 W 2nd St
    Zip 88201 Roswell - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($105 /month )
    High Country Agency Inc.
    706 Mechem Dr
    Zip 88345 Ruidoso - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($96 /month )
    Rio Grande Insurance Services Of Sf
    1231 S Saint Francis Dr
    Zip 87505 Santa Fe - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($106 /month )
    Capitol Insurance Services, LLC
    810 Calle Mejia
    Zip 87501 Santa Fe - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($95 /month )
    Insurance First Inc.
    1024 N Hudson St
    Zip 88061 Silver City - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($105 /month )
    Michael Olguin Insurance Associates LLC
    315 N California St
    Zip 87801 Socorro - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($96 /month )
    Wafd Insurance Group, Inc.
    304 S Foch St
    Zip 87901 T Or C - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($109 /month )
    Brown & Brown Insurance Of NM Inc.
    627 Paseo Del Pueblo Sur
    Zip 87571 Taos - New Mexico
  • Nationwide ($104 /month )
    Wafd Insurance Group, Inc.
    214 S 2nd St
    Zip 88401 Tucumcari - New Mexico

NJM

$1,257/yr


Progressive

$1,575/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by Progressive is $120 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.
  • Progressive ($116 /month )
    Route 66 Insurance - David Haemker
    8650 Alameda Blvd Ste 103-E
    Zip 87122 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($125 /month )
    Arthur Insurance Angel Fire
    3417 Hwy 434
    Zip 87710 Angel Fire - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($115 /month )
    Roadrunner Ins Agcy
    500 Anthony Dr
    Zip 88021 Anthony - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($112 /month )
    Foss Insurance Agency
    202 S Main
    Zip 87410 Aztec - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($130 /month )
    MAYNES INSURANCE AGENCY
    1207 Tom Foy Blvd
    Zip 88023 Bayard - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($118 /month )
    Blue Star Ins. Agency
    221 S. Main St
    Zip 87002 Belen - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($126 /month )
    Mountain Insurance Services
    12445 N Hwy 14
    Zip 87008 Cedar Crest - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($124 /month )
    Chavez Ortega Agency
    6366 Us 550
    Zip 87013 Cuba - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($128 /month )
    A. W. Pollard Insurance Agency, Inc.
    118 West Pine St
    Zip 88030 Deming - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($119 /month )
    Us United Group
    150 St Rd 344 Suite E
    Zip 87015 Edgewood - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($123 /month )
    Quintana Ins Agency
    309 S Paseo De Onate
    Zip 87544 Espanola - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($126 /month )
    Leavell Insurance
    902 Main
    Zip 88231 Eunice - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($129 /month )
    Insurance Services of New Mexico
    631 N 4th St
    Zip 88119 Fort Sumner - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($113 /month )
    Hector Baeza
    117 E. Broadway
    Zip 88240 Hobbs - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($119 /month )
    LEAVELL INS & RE
    122 S Main
    Zip 88252 Jal - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($122 /month )
    NavSav Holdings, LLC McGonigle Ins
    156 Wyatt Drive Suites 5-8
    Zip 88005 Las Cruces - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($122 /month )
    HUB International Insurance Services
    518 8th Street
    Zip 87701 Las Vegas - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($118 /month )
    Insurance Specialties
    1850 Main St Ste B
    Zip 87031 Los Lunas - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($120 /month )
    Western States Insurance Group Inc
    212 N. Love
    Zip 88260 Lovington - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($127 /month )
    Insurance Srvc Of Nm
    704 W.olde Route 66
    Zip 87035 Moriarty - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($122 /month )
    Arthur Insurance Agency
    126 S 3rd
    Zip 87740 Raton - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($115 /month )
    Hester Insurance
    7820 Enchanted Hillsblv Ne Stea#136
    Zip 87144 Rio Rancho - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($125 /month )
    Lopez Insurance Agency
    1904 S. Main St.
    Zip 88203 Roswell - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($115 /month )
    James H Russell Agency, Inc.
    1570 Pacheco St Bldg C
    Zip 87504 Santa Fe - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($122 /month )
    Daniels Ins Agy Inc
    805 St. Michaels Dr.
    Zip 87502 Santa Fe - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($120 /month )
    Insurance Services of NM
    440 Corona Ave
    Zip 88435 Santa Rosa - New Mexico
  • Progressive ($119 /month )
    Tri-State Insurance Agency
    5647 Crawford Rd
    Zip 88008 Santa Teresa - New Mexico

Statefarm

$1,303/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by Statefarm is $99 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.
  • Statefarm ($104 /month )
    Marty Saiz
    1029 Montano Road NW
    Zip 87107-5234 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($105 /month )
    Tim Gallegos
    1100 Coors Blvd SW Suite B2
    Zip 87121-3404 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($90 /month )
    Paul Maestas
    111 Coors Blvd NW
    Zip 87121-2008 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($106 /month )
    Rosendo Aragon
    1808 Lomas Blvd NW Ste B
    Zip 87104-1206 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($99 /month )
    Gary Armijo
    2116 Vista Oeste Dr NW Ste 402
    Zip 87120-4343 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($94 /month )
    Leroy Gettler
    2500 Central Avenue SW Suite B100
    Zip 87104-1718 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($94 /month )
    Robert Pratt
    2800 San Mateo Blvd NE Ste 102
    Zip 87110-3166 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($105 /month )
    Monica Edwards
    300 Broadway Blvd NE Suite L
    Zip 87102-3488 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($93 /month )
    Ken Brudos
    3700 Coors BLVD NW
    Zip 87120-1405 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($92 /month )
    Michele Romero
    3904 Carlisle Blvd NE
    Zip 87107-4534 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($91 /month )
    Ron Pino
    4250 Coors Blvd SW
    Zip 87121-5500 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($102 /month )
    Matt Medina
    4253 Montgomery Blvd NE Suite #G205
    Zip 87109-1178 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($99 /month )
    Edward Dunn
    4420 4th Street NW
    Zip 87107-3933 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($105 /month )
    Chris Nathe
    5201 Ouray Road NW Suite E
    Zip 87120-3033 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($95 /month )
    Theresa Saiz-Wilmert
    6301 Riverside Plaza Lane NW
    Zip 87120-2638 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($95 /month )
    Ted Madrid
    6644 Caminito Coors NW
    Zip 87120-3119 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($92 /month )
    Brian Anastasio
    8625 Golf Course Road NW
    Zip 87114-5114 Albuquerque - New Mexico
  • Statefarm ($99 /month )
    Rick Buckner
    9601 Sage Road SW Suite D
    Zip 87121-6804 Albuquerque - New Mexico

Travelers

$1,397/yr

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico by Travelers is $102 per month at following Agent and Agency locations in New Mexico. Find an agent near your zip code. Click on your zip code link to get contact details and comparative quotes.
  • Travelers ($107 /month )
    Leavitt Group Southwest Inc
    1740 Calle De Mercado, Ste E
    Zip 88046 Mesilla - New Mexico

USAA

$1,016/yr


*Actual Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico may vary based on individual factors such as zip code, credit score, vehicle type, and age/sex of the driver.